DSA fines and enforcement in Germany: the DDG and the Bundesnetzagentur
The DSA sets the framework for penalties; each member state sets the actual fines. In Germany they are in the Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz. Here are the maximum fines per duty, who is in charge, and what the regulator has focused on so far.
The DSA is an EU regulation, but fines are set by each member state. This guide uses Germany as the worked example: the fines are in § 33 of the Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (DDG, the German Digital Services Act). It applies to providers that Germany supervises, which usually means providers with their main establishment in Germany. If you are based elsewhere, your national coordinator is on the Commission’s list, and the caps in Art. 52 DSA below apply everywhere.
Who is in charge: the Coordinator in the Bundesnetzagentur, BzKJ, BfDI
Under § 12 DDG, the Bundesnetzagentur (Federal Network Agency) is the competent authority for the DSA. Under § 14 DDG, the Koordinierungsstelle für digitale Dienste, Germany’s Digital Services Coordinator (DSC), is set up inside it, based in Bonn.
Two areas sit elsewhere:
- The Federal Agency for Child and Youth Protection in the Media (BzKJ) enforces Art. 14(3) (terms that minors can understand, for services aimed at or mainly used by minors) and structural precautions under Art. 28(1), unless the federal states are responsible under the interstate treaty on youth media protection. Section 33 DDG has no fine for Art. 28(1) itself; the BzKJ proceeds under section 24b of the Youth Protection Act (see protecting minors under Art. 28 DSA).
- The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI) handles Art. 26(3) and Art. 28(2) and (3): advertising based on sensitive data and profiling-based advertising to minors.
The DSA framework: caps for member states (Art. 52)
Art. 52 DSA requires member states to set effective, proportionate and dissuasive penalties, within these caps:
- 6 % of annual worldwide turnover in the preceding financial year for failing to comply with a DSA obligation,
- 1 % of annual income or worldwide turnover for supplying incorrect, incomplete or misleading information, failing to reply, or refusing an inspection,
- 5 % of average daily worldwide turnover per day as a periodic penalty payment.
Fines under the DDG
§ 33 DDG lists the DSA breaches that count as administrative offences in paragraphs 4 and 5, and sorts them into two bands in paragraph 6. Paragraph 5 covers intentional and negligent breaches. The table shows the items that matter most for apps with user content.
| Duty | DSA | § 33 DDG | Maximum |
|---|---|---|---|
| Repeated arbitrary or non-objective decisions on notices | Art. 16(6) | para. 4 | €300,000 |
| Setting up notice and action | Art. 16(1), (2) | para. 5 no. 8 | €300,000 |
| Providing a statement of reasons | Art. 17 | para. 5 no. 10 | €300,000 |
| Access to the internal complaint system | Art. 20(1)–(3) | para. 5 no. 11 | €300,000 |
| Reversing a decision after a justified complaint | Art. 20(4) | para. 5 no. 12 | €300,000 |
| Complaint decisions not taken solely by automated means | Art. 20(6) | para. 5 no. 14 | €300,000 |
| Priority for trusted flaggers | Art. 22(1) | para. 5 no. 16 | €300,000 |
| No personal data in Transparency Database submissions | Art. 24(5), 2nd sentence | para. 5 no. 18 | €300,000 |
| Informing users of significant changes to terms | Art. 14(2) | para. 5 no. 1 | €100,000 |
| Designating points of contact and a legal representative | Art. 11(1), 12(1), 13 | para. 5 no. 2 | €100,000 |
| Publishing point-of-contact details | Art. 11(2), (3), 12(2) | para. 5 no. 3 | €100,000 |
| Explaining terms so minors understand them | Art. 14(3) | para. 5 no. 6 | €100,000 |
| Transparency report | Art. 15, 24(1) | para. 5 no. 7 | €100,000 |
| Telling notifiers about the decision | Art. 16(5) | para. 5 no. 9 | €100,000 |
| Telling complainants about the decision | Art. 20(5) | para. 5 no. 13 | €100,000 |
| Making information on out-of-court dispute settlement accessible | Art. 21(1), 2nd subpara. | para. 5 no. 15 | €100,000 |
| User numbers on request, Transparency Database submission | Art. 24(3), 24(5) 1st sentence | para. 5 no. 17 | €100,000 |
Further items cover advertising, recommender systems, interface design and the marketplace duties in Art. 30–32.
Turnover-based caps. For legal persons and associations with total turnover above EUR 5 million, breaches in the €300,000 band can be fined up to 6 % of total turnover (§ 33(7) DDG). Above EUR 10 million, the €100,000 band rises to 1 % (§ 33(8)). Total turnover means all worldwide revenue in the financial year before the authority’s decision, and it may be estimated (§ 33(9)).
Who imposes the fine. The Digital Services Coordinator for almost all DSA offences, the BzKJ for Art. 14(3), the BfDI for Art. 26(3) and Art. 28(2) (§ 33(10)).
Not every duty is in the fines catalogue
§ 33 DDG does not list some duties, for example the content of the terms under Art. 14(1), the confirmation of receipt under Art. 16(4), notifying crimes under Art. 18 or suspensions under Art. 23. That does not make them optional: under Art. 51 DSA the regulator can still order you to end an infringement and impose periodic penalty payments.
How a case runs
In its June 2026 report to its advisory board (in German), the German DSC described its process:
- Trigger: often user complaints through its complaint portal. Under Art. 53 DSA, users can complain to the coordinator of their own country.
- Fact-finding: research on the website and in the app, checks such as the commercial register, and an information request to the provider.
- Formal information request: if a provider does not answer, answers incompletely or late, the DSC can issue a formal request backed by the threat of a periodic penalty. By June 2026 that had been needed once.
- Supervisory measures in two steps: first the DSC establishes an infringement and asks the provider to comment and fix it. If the provider does not, the DSC can order the necessary measures in a second step.
Fines run separately as administrative offence proceedings. For the Transparency Database, for example, the DSC is preparing fine hearings against platforms that still have not registered after being asked to.
What the regulator has focused on so far
From the same report (as of June 2026):
- 42 administrative proceedings opened. The focus is insufficient implementation of Art. 16 (notice and action), Art. 17 (statements of reasons) and Art. 20 (internal complaint handling), and for online marketplaces Art. 30 (trader traceability).
- 14 proceedings closed, mostly because providers brought their services into line after the information request.
- Transparency Database onboarding campaign (Art. 24(5)): letters to more than 100 providers, more than two thirds onboarded, some not obliged because they are micro or small enterprises. Fine hearings are being prepared against four providers.
- Most user complaints concern inadequate statements of reasons for restrictions and hard-to-use reporting channels, mainly at very large platforms based in Ireland.
For app teams the message is clear: regulators look closely at the processes every app with user content needs. How to set them up is covered in Notices under Art. 16, Statement of reasons under Art. 17, Internal complaint handling under Art. 20 and the DSA Transparency Database.
And the European Commission?
The Commission supervises very large online platforms and search engines, and has exclusive powers over their systemic risk duties (Art. 56(2) and (3) DSA). For smaller apps it is usually not the regulator.
On 5 December 2025 the Commission fined X EUR 120 million over the deceptive design of its blue checkmark, the lack of transparency of its ad repository and the failure to give researchers access to public data. The Commission called it the first non-compliance decision under the DSA (press release IP/25/2934). According to the German DSC’s June 2026 report, X challenged the decision before the EU General Court in February 2026.
Whether each duty applies to your app in the first place is covered in The DSA for apps, and what small companies can skip in DSA exemptions for micro and small enterprises. In a 30-minute demo we can check with you where your app stands.
Sources
- Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (DDG), § 33 fines (German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (DDG), § 12 competent authorities (German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (DDG), § 14 Digital Services Coordinator (German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act), Art. 52 Penalties, EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- German DSC, report to the advisory board, June 2026 (PDF, German)bundesnetzagentur.de
- European Commission, Digital Services Coordinatorsdigital-strategy.ec.europa.eu
- European Commission, press release IP/25/2934 (X fine), 5 December 2025ec.europa.eu