Protecting minors under Art. 28 DSA: what the Commission's guidelines mean for apps
Art. 28 DSA is short; the Commission's guidelines on it are not. This guide covers which apps are in scope, what the guidelines recommend on age assurance, default settings and reporting tools, how enforcement works, with Germany as an example, and what the proposed EU KIDS Act would add.
Learning apps, games with chat, social apps for teenagers: many apps are used by minors, even when they were not built for them. The Digital Services Act addresses this in Art. 28 DSA. What it requires in practice is set out in the Commission’s guidelines of July 2025. This guide summarises both for app teams, with paragraph numbers (para.) so you can check the source.
Who Art. 28 applies to
Art. 28 is addressed to providers of online platforms accessible to minors. Two conditions, then: your app is an online platform, meaning it disseminates user content to the public (see the DSA for apps), and minors can use it.
When a platform is “accessible to minors” is explained in recital 71. That is the case when
- its terms and conditions permit minors to use the service,
- the service is directed at or predominantly used by minors, or
- the provider is otherwise aware that some users are minors, for example because it already processes personal data that reveals their age.
The guidelines tighten this: a ban in your terms is not enough on its own. A provider that does not effectively keep minors out cannot rely on its terms saying the app is 18+ (para. 6). Further signs the Commission lists include asking for age at sign-up, the platform being known to appeal to minors, being promoted to them, or offering services similar to those used by minors (para. 7).
The exemption for micro and small enterprises
Art. 19 exempts micro and small enterprises from the whole section on online platforms (Art. 19 to 28), except Art. 24(3). That covers all of Art. 28, including the advertising ban in paragraph 2 and the rule on extra data in paragraph 3. The guidelines confirm the exemption for paragraph 1 (para. 8). Three details:
- If your company grows past the thresholds, the exemption still applies for 12 months.
- Very large online platforms are never exempt.
- Partner and linked enterprises count towards the thresholds under Recommendation 2003/361/EC. A small app team inside a large group is therefore usually not exempt.
What counts as small is covered in the guide on exemptions for micro and small enterprises.
Art. 14(3) applies to everyone
Regardless of size, Art. 14(3) applies to every intermediary service: if a service is primarily directed at minors or predominantly used by them, its terms must be explained in a way minors can understand. See the guide on points of contact and terms.
The wording: a high level of privacy, safety and security
Art. 28(1) reads:
Providers of online platforms accessible to minors shall put in place appropriate and proportionate measures to ensure a high level of privacy, safety, and security of minors, on their service.
The law does not say which measures. Paragraph 4 allows the Commission to issue guidelines, which it has done.
No profiling-based ads to minors
Art. 28(2) bans advertising based on profiling, as defined in the GDPR, when the provider is aware with reasonable certainty that the user is a minor. If you know from sign-up that a user is 15, you must not show them personalised ads based on their profile. Contextual ads that depend only on the content currently shown fall outside the ban on its wording, because they do not rely on profiling.
No duty to collect extra data
Art. 28(3) makes clear that complying with Art. 28 does not oblige you to process additional personal data just to assess whether someone is a minor. Recital 71 grounds this in the data minimisation principle.
That is not a free pass. The guidelines still recommend age assurance as a protective measure under paragraph 1 in certain cases, in a data-minimising way, for example through anonymised age tokens (para. 41). Paragraph 3 only means that the advertising ban alone does not force you to collect ages.
What the guidelines recommend
The guidelines are not binding. The Commission does, however, limit its own discretion: the guidelines may be considered “a significant and meaningful benchmark” on which it will base itself when applying Art. 28(1) (para. 12). That cuts both ways: implementing every measure does not automatically mean you comply (para. 12). Nor is the list exhaustive (para. 15).
Not every measure suits every platform. What is appropriate and proportionate follows from a risk review (section 5, paras. 17 to 21). At a minimum it covers how likely minors are to use your app, which risks they face, which measures you already have and which you add, how you measure their effect, and how all this affects children’s rights (para. 18). You repeat it at least once a year and whenever you make significant design changes, and you publish the outcome without disclosing sensitive operational information (para. 21). The key points for apps:
Age assurance
The guidelines use “age assurance” as the umbrella term and distinguish three methods (para. 29): self-declaration (the user states their age or clicks “I am over 18”), age estimation (the age is approximated) and age verification (based on verified sources of identification).
- Assess first, restrict second. Before restricting access by age, check whether that is appropriate and proportionate or whether less far-reaching measures suffice. Publish the outcome on your interface, even if you conclude that no restriction is needed (paras. 31, 32).
- Age verification is considered appropriate for alcohol, tobacco, drugs, pornography and gambling, where your terms require users to be 18 for risk reasons, where a law sets a minimum age, and for risks that cannot be mitigated otherwise. The Commission expressly includes contact risks from features such as live chat, image or video sharing and anonymous messaging (para. 37).
- Age estimation is foreseen for minimum ages below 18 and for medium risks (para. 47).
- Self-declaration is not considered an appropriate method because it is not robust and accurate enough (para. 52).
- Often it is enough to restrict specific features rather than the whole app (para. 36).
Private by default
Minors’ accounts should be set to the highest level of privacy, safety and security by default (para. 57). As a minimum, the Commission lists that only accepted contacts can interact (comment, tag, message) and only accepted contacts can see the minor’s content and profile details. Minors should also be able to restrict the visibility of their profile photo and their content, and to accept or reject tags by other users (para. 59(c) and (d)).
Moderation
On top of the duties in Art. 14 to 17, the guidelines recommend (para. 72):
- defining clearly which content and behaviour harms minors, and explaining it understandably when the account is set up,
- prioritising by severity and prioritising reports made by minors,
- human review in addition to automated review,
- moderation around the clock, with at least one person on call for emergencies,
- moderation in the official languages of the Member States where the app is offered,
- technical detection of known harmful and illegal content, such as hash matching and URL detection.
Separately from Art. 28, Art. 18 applies to every hosting service: if you become aware of information giving rise to a suspicion of a criminal offence that threatens someone’s life or safety, you inform the law enforcement or judicial authorities. Recital 56 expressly mentions child sexual abuse.
Reporting with feedback
Reporting tools should be child-friendly, visible and easy to reach (para. 77). Among other things, the guidelines recommend that:
- minors can report content, accounts and groups, and all users can report a suspected underage account where the terms set a minimum age,
- minors can give their own reasons; if there are categories, the youngest users must be able to understand them,
- reports are confidential and anonymous by default,
- minors can flag a report as urgent,
- every minor who reports gets a confirmation of receipt without undue delay, an age-appropriate explanation of the process, an indicative timeframe and an explanation of the outcome.
Add block and mute buttons and links to support services such as child helplines. When a minor reports harmful content, the link to support should appear right after the report (para. 78). How to take and answer notices in general is covered in the guide on notices under Art. 16 DSA.
Tools for guardians
Parental tools should be easy to use and show the child when they are active (para. 81). They complement the other measures and never replace them (para. 80).
Status of the guidelines
The Commission published the guidelines on 14 July 2025; they appeared in the Official Journal as C/2025/5519 on 10 October 2025. It committed to reviewing them when needed and at the latest after 12 months (para. 92). That deadline passed in July 2026. As of 9 October 2026, there was no revised version and no consultation on one. Check for a newer version before you make implementation decisions.
Who enforces it, and the fines
Art. 28 is enforced by the Digital Services Coordinator or another competent authority of the Member State where the provider is established, and by the Commission for very large platforms. The Commission keeps a list of Digital Services Coordinators. Several Member States spread the competences across authorities. Fines are set by national law within the caps of Art. 52 DSA, and not every part of Art. 28 is necessarily covered by a fine.
Example: Germany
Who. Under section 12 of the Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (DDG), the Federal Agency for the Protection of Children and Young Persons in the Media (BzKJ) enforces Art. 14(3) and structural precautionary measures under Art. 28(1), through its unit for the enforcement of children’s rights in digital services (KidD). The state media authorities handle measures under the interstate treaty on youth media protection. The Federal Data Protection Commissioner (BfDI) is responsible for Art. 28(2) and (3). Everything else sits with the Digital Services Coordinator at the Bundesnetzagentur. Suspicions of criminal offences under Art. 18 go to the Federal Criminal Police Office (BKA) as the central point (section 13 DDG).
What. Since May 2024, section 24a of the Youth Protection Act (JuSchG) implements Art. 28(1) and calls the measures “precautionary measures”. Its non-exhaustive list starts with a notice and action mechanism with child-friendly guidance, through which minors can report user content that harms their personal integrity. It goes on with self-rating of audiovisual content as 18+, age verification for such content, an easy-to-find pointer to independent advice, help and reporting services, parental tools and safe default settings.
How. Under section 24b JuSchG, jugendschutz.net makes a first assessment. If the BzKJ finds the measures insufficient, it first hears and advises the provider, then sets a deadline, and only then can it order measures itself. The BzKJ opened proceedings against numerous platforms in 2023, focusing on their reporting systems. In April 2026, the KidD presented its review criteria: a risk analysis of the platform, then the measures in place, how effective they are and what is still missing. Because of the country-of-origin principle, which section 24a(4) leaves untouched, the KidD supervises platforms established in Germany. As section 24a only enforces Art. 28(1), we read the Art. 19 exemption for micro and small enterprises as applying here too.
Fines. Section 33 DDG has no fine for Art. 28(1) itself. Breaching an enforceable order of the BzKJ can be fined up to EUR 5 million (section 28(3) no. 4 and (5) JuSchG). For companies, that maximum can rise tenfold, because the provision refers to section 30(2), third sentence, of the Administrative Offences Act. Profiling-based ads to minors under Art. 28(2) can be fined by the BfDI up to EUR 300,000, or up to 6 % of turnover for companies with a total turnover above EUR 5 million (section 33(5) no. 26 and (7) DDG). Terms that minors cannot understand (Art. 14(3)) can be fined by the BzKJ up to EUR 100,000, or up to 1 % above EUR 10 million turnover (section 33(5) no. 6 and (8) DDG). See DSA fines in Germany for the full list.
What the Commission is enforcing now
On 26 March 2026, the Commission opened formal proceedings against Snapchat as a joint investigation with the Dutch coordinator, which had started the case in September 2025. They concern, among other things, age assurance, a design that may allow minors to be contacted for sexual exploitation or criminal recruitment, default settings and reporting tools. On the same day, the Commission published preliminary findings against the adult platforms Pornhub, Stripchat, XNXX and XVideos: self-declaration, blurring and warnings did not keep minors out.
On 29 April 2026 came preliminary findings against Meta for Instagram and Facebook: children under 13 were not effectively kept out, and the date of birth could be entered freely. Relevant for reporting tools: reporting a suspected underage account took up to seven clicks just to reach the form, and the form was not pre-filled. In July 2026, according to news reports, preliminary findings against TikTok followed, over minors’ accounts not being private by default (JURIST). We could not retrieve the Commission’s own press release on it.
None of these steps is a final decision, and as of October 2026 we found no decision imposing a fine under Art. 28. All of them concern very large platforms and also rely on the systemic risk duties in Art. 34 and 35, so they do not translate one to one to smaller apps. Still, according to the German coordinator’s June 2026 report to its advisory board, the Commission based its Snapchat and adult platform investigations on the 2025 guidelines, which is the clearest sign yet that the guidelines work as the yardstick in practice.
What is coming: the EU KIDS Act
On 17 September 2026, the Commission published its proposal for an EU KIDS Act (COM(2026) 681). It covers, among others, social networks, video-sharing platforms, online games and app stores accessible to minors. Micro and small enterprises are expressly not exempt from its scope; the draft only spares them individual duties such as the risk assessment. Article 19 of the draft requires child-friendly reporting tools, priority handling of reports by minors without undue delay, and pointers to support services after every report. Complying with the KIDS Act would, to that extent, also satisfy Art. 28(1).
This is a proposal, not law. Parliament and Council still have to deal with it, and the text may change. It would apply six months after entry into force; commentators do not expect that before 2028.
What Limenia covers and what it does not
Limenia does not provide age assurance or age verification, parental tools, or settings for profiles or recommendations in your app. Those stay with you or specialised providers, as do the confirmation of receipt, blocking and the pointer to support services inside your app. Limenia covers the reporting and decision side: decisions with plain-language statements of reasons, appeals against decisions, and feedback to the reporter under Art. 16(5). Reported images stay blurred until someone reveals them. Reports with the reason codes child_safety or protection_of_minors are marked urgent straight away; Limenia stores no copy of their media and deletes copies already stored. You can filter the queue for urgent cases. For games, see moderation for games with chat.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act), Art. 14, 18, 19, 28 and 52, recitals 56 and 71, EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- Commission guidelines on measures to ensure a high level of privacy, safety and security for minors online (C/2025/5519, OJ C of 10.10.2025), EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- European Commission: Commission publishes guidelines on the protection of minors (July 2025)digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu
- European Commission: Digital Services Coordinatorsdigital-strategy.ec.europa.eu
- European Commission: Commission investigates Snapchat (26 March 2026)digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu
- European Commission Representation in Cyprus: preliminary findings against Meta (29 April 2026)cyprus.representation.ec.europa.eu
- JURIST: preliminary findings against TikTok (July 2026, secondary source)jurist.org
- Proposal for a Regulation (EU KIDS Act), COM(2026) 681 of 17 September 2026, EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- European Commission: The KIDS Act explaineddigital-strategy.ec.europa.eu
- Section 24a Jugendschutzgesetz (precautionary measures, German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Section 24b Jugendschutzgesetz (powers and procedure, German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Section 28 Jugendschutzgesetz (administrative fines, German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Section 30 Gesetz über Ordnungswidrigkeiten (fines against legal persons, German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Section 12 Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (German competent authorities, German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Section 13 Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (notifications to the Federal Criminal Police Office, German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Section 33 Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (administrative fines, German)gesetze-im-internet.de
- BzKJ: review criteria for online providers (20 April 2026, German)bzkj.de
- BzKJ: proceedings over insufficient structural precautionary measures (3 November 2023, German)bzkj.de
- Report of the German DSC to its advisory board, June 2026 (PDF, German)bundesnetzagentur.de