Statement of reasons under Art. 17 DSA: required content and examples
Whenever you restrict someone’s content or account, you owe them a statement of reasons. This guide covers when it is due, what Art. 17(3) DSA requires and what a good one reads like in an app.
The statement of reasons is the part of the DSA your users actually see. It tells them why a comment disappeared or why they can’t sign in for a week. Article 17 DSA sets out when you must send one and what it must contain at a minimum.
The duty applies to every hosting service, whatever its size. The micro and small enterprise exemptions in Art. 19 do not reach it.
The full text of Article 17 DSA is at the end of this guide.
When you must send a statement of reasons
Art. 17(1) lists four kinds of restriction. A statement is due whenever you impose one of them because content is illegal or breaks your terms and conditions:
| Restriction | Art. 17(1) | Examples from apps |
|---|---|---|
| Visibility | (a) | comment removed, profile photo hidden, post demoted in the feed, listing blocked |
| Monetary payments | (b) | payout to a creator suspended, monetisation of a post ended |
| The service | (c) | chat disabled for one person, uploads switched off |
| The account | (d) | account suspended for seven days, account closed for good |
It doesn’t matter whether the decision followed a notice, your own review or an automatic filter. Recital 55 adds less visible measures: demotion in rankings or recommendations, and excluding someone from a community without their knowledge (“shadow banning”).
Timing: the duty applies at the latest from the date the restriction is imposed (Art. 17(2)). The statement comes with the measure, not days later.
When not
Art. 17 has three exceptions:
- No contact details. The duty only applies where you know the person’s electronic contact details (Art. 17(2)). In apps with sign-in you usually have at least an email address.
- Deceptive high-volume commercial content (Art. 17(2), second subparagraph). Recital 55 describes it as content spread through intentional manipulation of the service, such as bots or fake accounts. A bot network posting a thousand scam links gets no individual statements. A real user’s promotional comment does.
- Orders under Art. 9 (Art. 17(5)). If you remove content because an authority ordered you to, Art. 17 does not apply. Instead, Art. 9(5) requires you to inform the person of the order, including a statement of reasons, redress options and its territorial scope.
The six required elements
Art. 17(3) lists what a statement must contain “at least”. Each element with a short example sentence:
(a) The measure, its territorial scope and its duration. What exactly you did and for how long.
“We have suspended your account from 9 October 2026, 14:00, until 16 October 2026, 14:00. The suspension applies throughout the app.”
(b) The facts and circumstances, including whether the decision followed a notice under Art. 16 or your own investigation. Name the notifier only where strictly necessary.
“Another user reported three of your messages from 8 October. In them, you repeatedly insulted that user.”
(c) Use of automated means, where applicable, including whether the content was detected automatically.
“The messages were not detected automatically. A member of our moderation team reviewed them and made the decision.”
(d) The legal ground with an explanation, if you consider the content illegal.
“In our assessment, the messages constitute the offence of insult under Section 185 of the German Criminal Code, because they disparage the person without any factual context.”
(e) The contractual ground with an explanation, if the decision relies on your terms and conditions.
“They also breach section 3.2 of our community guidelines (“No bullying, no insults”), because they target one specific person.”
(f) Redress options, clear and user-friendly: where applicable, internal complaint handling, out-of-court dispute settlement and the courts.
“You can appeal within six months in the app under Settings > Help > Appeal a decision. You can also turn to a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body or go to court.”
Art. 17(4) sets the standard: clear, easily comprehensible, and as precise and specific as reasonably possible in the circumstances. The person must be able to challenge the decision effectively. “Your content violates our guidelines” does not meet that bar.
List the redress you actually offer
Point (f) asks for redress options “where applicable”. If you run an online platform and are not a micro or small enterprise, include the internal complaint system under Art. 20 and a pointer to out-of-court dispute settlement under Art. 21. If Art. 19 exempts you, name what you do offer, and in every case the courts.
Law or terms: two kinds of grounds
Points (d) and (e) distinguish two grounds, and the difference matters:
- Illegal content (d): name the legal provision and explain why the content falls under it. Illegality often depends on the country, so restricting content in one Member State only can make sense. Point (a) then requires you to state that territorial scope.
- Breach of your terms (e): name the specific rule, ideally with its section or title, and explain why the content breaks it. The rule must actually exist in your terms; Art. 14 requires you to set out all restrictions there.
Many cases are both, for example an insult that also breaks your community guidelines. You can cite both grounds. A rule in your terms is often easier to assess than a criminal offence and applies the same way throughout the app; cite the law where you actually rely on it.
Disclosing automation
Point (c) requires information on whether automated means were used in the decision and whether the content was detected automatically. In practice there are three cases:
- No automation: reported, reviewed and decided by a person.
- Automated detection, human decision: a filter or AI pre-check flagged the content, a person decided.
- Automated decision: a system removed the content without human review.
State the applicable case in one sentence. For more, including the ban on purely automated complaint decisions, see automated and AI content moderation under the DSA.
Examples
The texts below are illustrative examples, not vetted legal templates. Adapt them to your app, your terms and your redress options, and have them checked. Examples 2 and 3 cite German law to show what a concrete legal ground looks like; use the law that applies to your case.
Example 1: comment removed as spam (terms)
We removed your comment
Your comment of 3 October 2026 under the post “Autumn recipes” is no longer visible to anyone as of today. The removal applies throughout the app and is permanent.
The comment advertised an online shop with a link and a discount code. We found it during our own review, not following a report. A person detected it and made the decision; no automated means were used.
The ground is section 4 of our community guidelines (“No advertising and no spam”), which prohibits promoting your own or other people’s offers in comments. Your comment was clearly intended to bring customers to the shop.
You can appeal within six months in the app under Settings > Help > Appeal a decision. You can also turn to a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body or go to court.
Example 2: account suspended for seven days (terms and law)
This example contains every required element from (a) to (f), labelled for reference:
Your account is temporarily suspended
(a) Measure: We have suspended your account from 9 October 2026, 14:00, until 16 October 2026, 14:00. During this time you cannot sign in, and your posts are not visible to others. The suspension applies throughout the app. Your account will be reactivated automatically afterwards.
(b) Facts: On 8 October 2026, another user reported three direct messages from you. In them, you repeatedly call that user names and encourage others to message them as well. You received a warning for a similar message on 12 September 2026.
(c) Automation: The messages were not detected by automated means. A member of our moderation team reviewed them and decided on the suspension.
(d) Legal ground: In our assessment, the messages constitute the offence of insult under Section 185 of the German Criminal Code. They disparage the person without any apparent factual reason.
(e) Contractual ground: They also breach section 3.2 of our community guidelines (“No bullying, no insults”). Under section 7, after a warning we suspend accounts for up to 30 days for repeated breaches.
(f) Redress: You can appeal within six months, also during the suspension, using the link in this email or on the sign-in screen. A person will review your appeal. You can also turn to a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body; the European Commission keeps the list. You can go to court at any time.
When an account is suspended, the person often can’t open the app. Send the statement by email or show it on the sign-in screen.
Example 3: profile photo hidden after a notice (law)
Your profile photo has been hidden
We have hidden your profile photo from other users as of today. This applies throughout the app until you upload a different photo.
Someone reported that the photo shows them and was published without their consent. They plausibly showed that they are the person pictured. A member of our team reviewed the report; no automated means were involved.
Under Section 22 of the German Art Copyright Act (Kunsturhebergesetz), images of a person may only be distributed with their consent. We cannot see any consent or legal exception.
You can appeal within six months in the app, for example if the person did consent. You can also turn to a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body or go to court.
Statements of reasons and the Transparency Database
If you run an online platform and are not exempt under Art. 19, you must also submit each decision and statement of reasons under Art. 17(1) to the Commission’s DSA Transparency Database without undue delay (Art. 24(5)). The submission must not contain personal data. The database uses structured fields that largely follow the elements of Art. 17(3), so generating your statements in a structured way pays off. How submission works is covered in the DSA Transparency Database guide.
Example: Germany
Germany’s Digital Services Coordinator reported in June 2026 that user complaints mostly concern insufficient reasons for restrictions, and named Art. 17 as a focus of the 42 proceedings it had opened by then. Missing or incomplete statements can be fined up to EUR 300,000 under § 33 DDG.
How the person can challenge the decision is covered in internal complaint handling under Art. 20 DSA. The full flow is on DSA notice and action for your app.
How to do this with Limenia
Limenia creates a statement of reasons for every restrictive decision. Your app receives it with the decision.created webhook as ready-made text in German or English, plus structured fields for your own layout. Whether automated means were involved is stated in the text and in the automation field. You set the redress text once in the settings. For developers: section 4.7 of the integration guide shows how to display the statement.
Full text of Article 17 DSA
Article 17 – Statement of reasons
1. Providers of hosting services shall provide a clear and specific statement of reasons to any affected recipients of the service for any of the following restrictions imposed on the ground that the information provided by the recipient of the service is illegal content or incompatible with their terms and conditions:
(a) any restrictions of the visibility of specific items of information provided by the recipient of the service, including removal of content, disabling access to content, or demoting content;
(b) suspension, termination or other restriction of monetary payments;
(c) suspension or termination of the provision of the service in whole or in part;
(d) suspension or termination of the recipient of the service’s account.
2. Paragraph 1 shall only apply where the relevant electronic contact details are known to the provider. It shall apply at the latest from the date that the restriction is imposed, regardless of why or how it was imposed.
Paragraph 1 shall not apply where the information is deceptive high-volume commercial content.
3. The statement of reasons referred to in paragraph 1 shall at least contain the following information:
(a) information on whether the decision entails either the removal of, the disabling of access to, the demotion of or the restriction of the visibility of the information, or the suspension or termination of monetary payments related to that information, or imposes other measures referred to in paragraph 1 with regard to the information, and, where relevant, the territorial scope of the decision and its duration;
(b) the facts and circumstances relied on in taking the decision, including, where relevant, information on whether the decision was taken pursuant to a notice submitted in accordance with Article 16 or based on voluntary own-initiative investigations and, where strictly necessary, the identity of the notifier;
(c) where applicable, information on the use made of automated means in taking the decision, including information on whether the decision was taken in respect of content detected or identified using automated means;
(d) where the decision concerns allegedly illegal content, a reference to the legal ground relied on and explanations as to why the information is considered to be illegal content on that ground;
(e) where the decision is based on the alleged incompatibility of the information with the terms and conditions of the provider of hosting services, a reference to the contractual ground relied on and explanations as to why the information is considered to be incompatible with that ground;
(f) clear and user-friendly information on the possibilities for redress available to the recipient of the service in respect of the decision, in particular, where applicable through internal complaint-handling mechanisms, out-of-court dispute settlement and judicial redress.
4. The information provided by the providers of hosting services in accordance with this Article shall be clear and easily comprehensible and as precise and specific as reasonably possible under the given circumstances. The information shall, in particular, be such as to reasonably allow the recipient of the service concerned to effectively exercise the possibilities for redress referred to in of paragraph 3, point (f).
5. This Article shall not apply to any orders referred to in Article 9.
Source: Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act), Official Journal of the EU L 277, 27 October 2022, p. 1. Only the version published in the Official Journal is authentic.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act), Article 17, EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, Recitals 54 and 55, EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, Article 24(5) (Transparency Database), EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- European Commission: DSA Transparency Databasetransparency.dsa.ec.europa.eu
- Germany: Digitale-Dienste-Gesetz (DDG), § 33 (fines)gesetze-im-internet.de
- Germany: report of the Digital Services Coordinator to its advisory board, June 2026 (PDF, German)bundesnetzagentur.de