Hosting service or online platform? How to classify your app under the DSA
Whether your app is "just" a hosting service or an online platform decides a dozen obligations. One question usually settles it: is your users' content disseminated to the public?
For apps with user content, the DSA has two tiers: the hosting service and the online platform. Both must run notice and action and give statements of reasons. Online platforms have a lot more to do on top, from complaint handling to trusted flaggers to the Transparency Database. It pays to know early which one your app is.
The definitions, word for word (Art. 3)
Art. 3 DSA defines:
Hosting service (point (g)(iii)): a service “consisting of the storage of information provided by, and at the request of, a recipient of the service”.
Online platform (point (i)): “a hosting service that, at the request of a recipient of the service, stores and disseminates information to the public, unless that activity is a minor and purely ancillary feature of another service or a minor functionality of the principal service and, for objective and technical reasons, cannot be used without that other service, and the integration of the feature or functionality into the other service is not a means to circumvent the applicability of this Regulation”.
Dissemination to the public (point (k)): “making information available, at the request of the recipient of the service who provided the information, to a potentially unlimited number of third parties”.
So every online platform is a hosting service, but not every hosting service is a platform. Whether a service counts as hosting at all depends on its technical functions and is assessed case by case (recital 29). If your app stores users’ text, photos, profiles or messages on your server or in your cloud project, it almost always does.
The deciding factor: dissemination to the public
Recital 14 explains that disseminating to the public means making information easily accessible to users in general, without further action by the person who posted it. Whether anyone actually looks is irrelevant. The dissemination also has to happen at the direct request of the person who provided the information.
Registration and groups: when content is still public
Many apps only show content after sign-in. That alone does not make it private. Recital 14 says that where access requires registration or admission to a group, the content counts as disseminated to the public if users are registered or admitted automatically, without a human decision or selection of whom to let in.
In practice:
- Anyone can create an account and then see all posts: probably public.
- A group anyone can join with one tap: probably public.
- A group where a moderator admits each person individually: probably not public.
- An app only for a company’s staff, with accounts approved by HR: probably not public.
Private messages and closed chats
Interpersonal communication services such as email or private messaging fall outside the definition of an online platform. They are used for communication between a finite number of people determined by the sender (recital 14). A one-to-one chat, or a group chat with invited contacts, is therefore usually not dissemination to the public.
The recital draws a line, though: the platform obligations may apply to services that make information available to a potentially unlimited number of recipients not chosen by the sender, such as public groups or open channels.
Keep in mind that a chat-only app is still usually a hosting service if it stores messages. Art. 16 and 17 apply either way.
Comment sections as an ancillary feature
Recital 13 illustrates the exception for minor features: the comments section of an online newspaper can be such a feature where it is clearly ancillary to the main service, publishing news under the publisher’s editorial responsibility. Storing comments in a social network, by contrast, is an online platform service, even if the comments sit alongside users’ posts.
For apps, a comment feature under your own articles, recipes or course material can be ancillary. If user posts are the core of the app, the exception usually does not apply. And it never applies where the setup is designed to get around the DSA.
Examples from apps
The table shows common features and how they are likely to be classified. It does not replace a check of your own case: details such as visibility settings or how people join groups often decide it.
| Feature | Likely classification | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Dating app profile photos visible to every signed-in user | Online platform | Anyone can sign up and browse profiles, with no human selection. |
| Public comments under other users’ posts | Online platform | User posts are the core of the service and visible to an open audience. |
| One-to-one chat between two users | Hosting service, not a platform | Interpersonal communication; the sender picks the recipient. |
| Open group channels anyone can join | Online platform | The audience is not chosen by the sender (recital 14). |
| Listings in a classifieds or marketplace app | Online platform, possibly with Art. 30–32 | Listings are meant to be found. Contracts with traders add marketplace duties. |
| Notes or cloud storage app, content only for the user’s own account | Hosting service, not a platform | Content is stored but not disseminated. If the app shares via public links, look more closely. |
| Comments under editorial content in a learning or news app | Hosting service, possibly ancillary | Can be a minor ancillary feature under recital 13. |
If your app combines several of these, look at the public ones. A single feature that disseminates to the public and is not merely ancillary is likely to make the whole app an online platform. That is why games with open chat channels and community apps often end up there, even when private chat is the most used feature.
What follows from the classification
| Classification | Obligations |
|---|---|
| Hosting service (not a platform) | Art. 11–18 |
| Online platform, micro or small enterprise | Art. 11–18 (without the transparency report) and Art. 24(3) |
| Online platform, larger | Art. 11–28 |
The full overview with a checklist is in The DSA for apps. Whether a small team is exempt from the platform duties is covered in DSA exemptions for micro and small enterprises.
At either tier you need a working notice and action process and a statement of reasons for every restriction. The page DSA notice and action for your app shows what that looks like in an app.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act), Art. 3, EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- DSA, recital 13 (ancillary features), EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- DSA, recital 14 (dissemination to the public), EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu
- DSA, recital 29 (hosting services), EUR-Lexeur-lex.europa.eu